Also known as "chef's choice" or "you pick" requests: the villager will request a type of insect, fish, fruit, or flower, and the player can choose from their inventory what to give. The potential rewards will depend on what rarity-tier item is given to the villager, as well as the player's friendship level with the villager.
*The only fortune cookies possible to receive through fulfilling requests are: Clothing Fortune Cookie, Timmy's Fortune Cookie, and Tommy's Fortune Cookie.